REAL ESTATE

Is Property Market Valuation an Unrealized Tax?

Real Estate - Is Property Market Evaluation an Unrealized Tax 11-15-26

As discussed in Chapter 7 of our publication When to Buy and When to Sell: Combining Easy Indicators, Charts, and Financial Astrology (available on Amazon), and several previous blogs, the purchase of a home may be one of the biggest decisions, and investments, to make in one’s lifetime. Over the last few years, we have consistently mentioned the issue of affordability, as it has never been more difficult for young buyers to purchase, with rising inflation, property prices, and property taxes/insurance, and the situation appears to be only getting worse, as is evident with an increasing number of defaults and foreclosures.

      That leads to an increasingly important question/debate whether Property Market Evaluation is an Unrealized Tax.

      When a property is purchased, it has a specific sales price that is agreed to by the buyer and seller. At the time of purchase, the buyer is legally informed of mortgage interest, closing fees, commissions, extra assessments, repair needs (through inspection), the current “market value” appraisal of the home (through comparative analysis), and the current annual property taxes levied by the town or county tax assessors.

      Property taxes have become a point of contention, however, calling into question the legality and potential fraud involved in the formulation of evaluations, and the possible over-taxing of property owners. One of the main issues argued in the raising of property taxes is the fact that some see these levies as an Unrealized Gains Tax.

      An Unrealized Gain can be defined as the increase in the value of an asset or investment that you own, but have not yet sold, meaning the profit exists only on paper. This occurs when the current market value of the asset is higher than the original cost basis (purchase price plus any transaction costs).

      According to some, property market evaluation itself is not an unrealized tax, but rather an appraisal or assessment of a property’s value for purposes such as taxation, lending, or insurance. Whether it is considered “unrealized” depends on the context of the tax system, and the type of tax being applied. A market evaluation (or market value appraisal) is an estimate of the most probable price a property would bring in an open market transaction, usually based on a comparison to similar homes within a specific geological location (known as a Comparative Market Analysis, or CMA).

      Professional appraisers will also use factors including age of systems and cost of replacement, in combination with CMAs to assess property. Local governments, banks, or insurers may order an appraisal to determine the property’s value for tax, mortgage, or insurance purposes. According to them, this is not a tax payment; it is a valuation process.

      Opponents of this thought process are of the opinion that raising taxes on the “perceived” value of any unsold asset is nothing more than an unrealized gains tax. The argument is strong as this suggests an asset holder is being taxed on zero “income,” especially for a single-family, owner-occupied property. How can I be taxed more on something I didn’t sell? – is the main argument. “Since the estimated market value is only comparative, and I’m not planning on selling, why would there be a tax increase?

      For example, when one makes a stock purchase, they hold the asset until they decide to sell. Aside from dividends, which is “income,” there are no taxes fluctuating by the perceived daily market price of that equity. Only when the asset is sold does the “sale price” become the viable “price” for which the amount of tax owed (known as capital gains) is calculated. In addition, when property taxes are raised based on perceived value, there are also no deductions factored in for repairs, replacements and/or any losses incurred with the property.

      U.S. federal tax law states that capital gains taxes apply only to realized gains. Property taxes, however, are reportedly based on taxable value (often tied to market value) and can rise when a property’s market value increases, even if the owner has not sold it. This means property tax can be seen as a tax on the value of the property, not just on realized gains. If the taxable value rises due to appreciation, the owner may owe more property tax before selling the property, which is why some economists describe it as a form of tax on unrealized gains.

      There are many lawsuits popping up across the country regarding the legality, and morality, of raising property taxes in this manner, beginning with Denton County, Texas, which we referred to in our real estate blog 2 months ago. The complaints have been gaining traction, though a significant amount of red tape, and non-transparency is involved, which is no surprise. Tune in to Travis and Mitch on their Real Estate Mindset U-Tube channel for more information.

      The bottom line is that taxing entities claim that property market evaluation is not an unrealized tax — it is a valuation. But in systems where property taxes are tied to market value, the resulting tax bill can be based on unrealized appreciation, which is why some refer to it as a “tax on unrealized gains.”  

      As always, a potential buyer should consult with a professional, real estate agent, or attorney, to make an informed decision, before purchasing property.

      Please visit the website www.augustassociatesllc.com for home values, listings, and professional assistance.

 

***As always, this information is not intended to be financial advice, or any specific buy or sell recommendation, but rather a guide to assist the reader in some further understanding of current economic conditions.

Previous
Previous

FEAR & GREED INDEX 39

Next
Next

FEAR & GREED INDEX 22